Gear reviews here at TMTB are organized in a specific way. There’s always an overview section to give you a quick rundown of the gear, its value, and whether it’s earned the TMTB Seal of Kickass Gear. Then, because I hope other gear nuts are reading, the reviews will get into the specifics of different aspects of the gear.
When you go shopping for a mid-priced rod (anything from $275-500) you likely don’t consider Orvis sticks. The mid-price market is dominated by Echo, Redington, Fenwick, Blue Halo, and some pretty decent Sage models.
Orvis has – rightfully so – earned a reputation of high quality over the years. As any angler knows, high quality is almost always accompanied by high price (the exception is the Echo Base, Fenwick Aetos, and Redington Hydrogen). But you don’t have to shell out a mortgage payment to own a quality Orvis stick, thanks to the Recon series.
The fine folks at Orvis sent me a 905-4 (9’5wt 4pc) Recon, and I spent a bit more than a month tossing it as my go-to 5wt. I’m primarily a dry-dropper fishermen, but I threw streamers and longer nymph rigs on the Recon as well.
Overall, I was impressed with a) the weight, b) the build quality, and c) the blue-collar attitude of the rod. This thing clocks in at 2 5/8oz, which is stupid light for a 5wt that has the backbone of the Recon. The build quality is what you’d expect from Orvis – high-grade cork, a beautiful dark wood burl insert for the reel seat, and black-nickel hardware.
Now, the Recon didn’t wow me in any specific category. Rather, I was impressed with how it managed nearly every fishing situation I threw its way. Dries to warily rising trout? No problem. Nymphing with a sighter leader? You bet. 5wt-sized streamers? Just don’t snag the tree behind you, because the Recon is a rocket that’ll shoot line in a laser if you’re a competent caster.
It felt like the fly rod for the blue-collar angler. If you don’t want to spend a ton of cash but still need a quality rod that’ll fish well and even put some trout on the table for dinner, the Recon deserves a wiggle test from your local fly shop. It sells for $425.
The 905-4 Recon earned the TMTB Seal of Kickass Gear
This rod is scary accurate – almost as good as the new Sage X. A competent caster won’t have issues getting this rod to put flies on a dinner plate up to 60 feet. Beyond that, most 5wt rods don’t pack the punch to be that accurate, but most trout fishing situations don’t require 60+ foot casts to begin with.
The blank stays straight, tracks well, and unless you’re up against a stiff wind you don’t have to work the rod too much to get your flies in the right spot.
I’ve switched my nymphing game up to Euro nymphing (thanks in large part to Lance Egan, Devin Olsen, and Gilbert Rowley, who produced the great “Modern Nymphing” film that’s a must-watch for every angler) so I don’t look at a roll cast like I used to, but the Recon did an exceptional job of lobbing an indicator, two weighted flies, and some split shot up and down the Lower Provo River.
Overall competency/Build quality
The Recon really is a rod you can comfortably use in any reasonable fly fishing situation. It handles dry flies, nymphs, and streamers very well, has a soft enough tip to protect your favorite skinny tippet, but the backbone to fight a larger trout’s run.
The build quality is typically Orvis, who’s churning out some of the best-looking production rods on today’s market.
I fish a lot of dry flies, and in the winter I’ll fish size 20-30 midges on a 14’ leader. The Recon didn’t turn these leaders over as well as other rods, like my Boron IIIx from Winston. I had to work the rod a bit with a short haul to get these leaders out, but again, for the price point of the Recon, it’s still great.
Not as great with the wind
The Recon does well in slight breezes, but in heavier winds it’s not as great as other 5wt rods. Again, though, it’s important to remember that this rod packs the performance of a much more expensive offering inside a sub-$500 price tag, so it’s hard to really nitpick it too much.
With the 25-year warranty from Orvis, a $425 price tag, exceptional build quality, and solid blue-collar performance in nearly every aspect of trout fishing, the 905-4 Recon is arguably the best mid-priced rod on today’s market. There’s a reason guides from Alaska to Patagonia have a Recon or two in their customer quivers – because these rods just work.
You can buy a Recon from our preferred fly shop, Fishwest.
Spencer Durrant is a novelist, outdoors columnist, and sports writer from Utah. He’s the managing editor of The Modern Trout Bum and a contributor to other major fly fishing publications. Connect with him on Twitter/Instagram @Spencer_Durrant.